Seanad passes Civil Engagement Group motion calling for immediate action on Palestine

22 February 2024

A motion tabled by the Civil Engagement Group calling for immediate and urgent Government action on Gaza successfully passed the Seanad this evening unopposed.

The motion, from Senators Frances Black, Alice-Mary Higgins, Lynn Ruane and Eileen Flynn, calls on the Government to end their blockage of the Occupied Territories Bill, support the South African ICJ case, press for suspension of EU-Israel trade, recognise the State of Palestine, and ensure that no munitions are being transferred to Israel via Ireland.

Currently 25% of Israel’s exports are to the European Union and Israel enjoys preferential access to the European Market under the EU-Israel Association Agreement. The motion calls on the Irish Government to press not just for a review but for suspension of the Agreement on human rights grounds,

The motion also calls on the Council of the European Union to advocate for an immediate and sustained ceasefire, to impose economic and diplomatic sanctions on Israel, and to substantially increase levels of humanitarian aid to Palestine, including the restoration of funding for UNWRA.

Welcoming the Government's decision not to oppose the motion, and the support from both opposition and Government Senators. the CEG Senators affirmed that now is the time for urgent action - business as usual cannot continue.

Speaking after the debate, Senator Frances Black thanked her colleagues across the House, stating: “The Seanad tonight sent a clear and resolute message that the Irish Government must be braver. Our words of condemnation are not enough, we must take strong and swift action given the scale of death and destruction we are observing in Gaza.”

“Gaza is now a graveyard for children. The people of Palestine, who are enduring unimaginable torture, deprivation and cruelty, need more than empty words of consolation. They need action. They need real tangible solidarity; nothing else will do.”

Senator Alice-Mary Higgins said: "This motion is a mandate for action. It calls on the Irish Government to pass the Occupied Territories Bill, press for immediate suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, recognise the State of Palestine, support South Africa in the ICJ case and ensure no weapons are passing through Ireland to Israel"

"We have seen the bravery of the doctors, mothers and children of Gaza in the face of unspeakable suffering and cruelty, Its time for Ireland to be braver and reflect tonight’s message from the Seanad and the Irish people’s commitment to peace, human rights and international law.”

Senator Eileen Flynn said: “We would not accept the killing of over 10,000 children in any EU country and we cannot accept it in Gaza. Our motion tonight is a reminder that human rights have to be for everyone and it shows real solidarity for the people of Palestine.

The motion was also tabled by Senator Lynn Ruane who was today speaking on the need for an immediate ceasefire at a meeting of the OSCE Young Parliamentarians.

More Stories

Government needs to act on concerns on Higher Education Authority Bill

14 July 2022

The Higher Education Authority Bill will have a major impact on staff, students & society. I proposed over 100 amendments. Following strong criticism of use of guillotine at Committee stage, Report stage has been adjourned, meaning there is still chance to improve crucial aspects of Bill.

One of the key issues I raised was the importance of trade union representation from both professional & academic staff on governance boards as well as proper national strategies to challenge the serious problem of precarious low paid work within academia.

The proposed definition of student union in the Bill is not fit for purpose & based around recognition from Minister or governing authority rather then electoral mandate from students. Students union representatives from right across country have made it clear this needs to be fixed!

The Bill will give huge amount of power & discretion to Minister, including requirement for higher education institutions to comply with future policy docs of Government. Bill must be amended to ensure appropriate independence, transparency & autonomy for both HEA & individual institutions.

Another core aspect we sought to address was embedding equality, equity, access and participation into the legislation and creating legal requirements that both HEA & individual institutions policies are furthering & empowering access to & equity in our higher education system.

The Bill continues the practice of focusing entirely on private research & not looking to public/blue skies research or public-public partnerships for research. To address issues like climate, inequality and sustainable development we need a robust public research system

The references to sustainability & environment in the Bill are woefully outdated & inadequate, coming from a 1987 pre-Rio definition of “environmental development”. I sought to include the definition based on the SDGs with acknowledgement of historical responsibility & climate justice.

Following pressure from Senators, the debate has adjourned till September & there is time for Minister Harris to work constructively with us as legislators & with stakeholders to address these & other issues. The HEA Bill will underpin higher education for years to come, we need to get it right!

Senator Alice-Mary Higgins urges European Parliamentarians to reject a proposal which would deny MEPs powers of oversight over the €13 billion European Defence Fund

18 April 2019

The proposal, due to be voted on by the parliament this week, in the last plenary session before the elections, would limit decisions on the work programme of the European Defence Fund to the European Commission and committees through “implementation acts”, effectively bypassing debate, criticism or approval from MEPs.

Senator Higgins calls on Irish Government to step up on climate justice ahead of COP27

28 October 2022

At the Joint Committee on Environment and Climate Action this week, ahead of COP27, the Committee heard powerful testimony from NGO's and activists working for climate justice ahead. The Committee were reminded of the stark reality by activist Elizabeth Wathuti who told us that "We are witnessing devastating Loss & Damage right now. From the devastating flooding across West and Central Africa; to the prolonged drought across the horn of Africa that has seen five consecutive rainy seasons fail."

NGOs highlighted the need for a number of policy measures to ensure that principles of climate justice are reflected in our global effort. A proper loss and damage facility, Ireland following Denmark's lead and beginning to make loss and damage payments as an individual country, proper climate finance and a fossil-fuel non-proliferation treaty are some of the key policy measures we were told are fundamental to climate justice.

When officials from the Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications came in, I specifically, asked them to ensure Ireland's support for a loss and damage facility for Global South countries and begin making payments as an individual country, I sought clarification that both loss and damage and climate finance measures would be additional to existing aid commitments and pushed for information on how Ireland intends to meet the 30% by 2030 methane pledge made at COP26.

I also sought a commitment that Ireland would support the inclusion of human rights in negotiated texts and a commitment that Ireland would sign the Declaration on Children, Youth and Climate Action.

Those who are already suffering the worst effects of the climate crisis and who have done the least to cause it, have been consistently let down by wealthy countries. Ireland must fight for climate justice at COP27.