“Comprehensive and detailed further scrutiny of CETA must now be undertaken by a number of other Oireachtas committees”


Independent Senator Alice-Mary Higgins has called for other Oireachtas Committees to undertake scrutiny of the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) following the split-decision of the Joint Committee on European Union Affairs on the need for further scrutiny. 




Seven members of the Committee reported that “there are real and unresolved concerns for the implications of implementing ICS in respect of sovereignty and public policy of member states” and “resolutions to ratify CETA should not be presented to Dáil Éireann or Seanad Éireann, so as to enable a vital wide ranging national political inquiry and debate across all sections of society on the implications of ratification.” 

Senator Higgins said: “Following the publication of the Committee’s report it is clear that CETA needs further scrutiny and examination, especially in light of the impact ratification will have on public policy in Ireland and other EU member states.” 

“Scrutiny of CETA is currently on the work programme for the Committee on Environment and Climate Action, the Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform, and the Committee on Justice. These Committees – and indeed other Oireachtas Committees must be given the opportunity to scrutinise the impacts of CETA and the Investor Court System (ICS).”

“CETA and ICS have implications for Ireland which reach far beyond the scope of any single Oireachtas Committee. TDs and Senators must be given the opportunity to consider the regulatory ‘chill effect’ created by ICS will impact public policy in respect of specific areas such as climate, health, housing, and public finances.”

“Fear of litigation will prevent successive governments from enacting vital public policy measures and regulations on issues such as the climate and biodiversity crises, the housing crisis and workers’ rights.”

“The tide is going out on trade agreements which contain investor-state arbitration mechanisms such as CETA. The recent decision on the Energy Charter Treaty and the lack of investor-state arbitration mechanisms in new trade agreements such as the USMCA, clearly demonstrates that governments across the world are recognising the threat to regulation that such mechanism pose. If CETA is fully ratified by all member states it will take thirty years to exit. Comprehensive and detailed scrutiny from multiple Committees policy perspectives is the least the public can expect when it comes to a decision which such far reaching implications.”


More Stories

Senator Alice-Mary Higgins welcomes decision not to permit hedge-cutting in August and calls on Minister Madigan to review the Heritage Act and to protect biodiversity

The decision by the Minister not to extend hedge-cutting into August this year is an important recognition of the growing crisis in biodiversity in Ireland and worldwide.
Senator Higgins said in response to today’s announcement, “I am glad to see Minister Madigan has apparently given new consideration to the serious concerns expressed by myself and others during the extensive Seanad Debate in the Heritage Bill and has removed the threat of August cutting from the habitats which our insects, birds, bees rely on. The essential next step must be to review this flawed legislation and ensure that biodiversity is protected not just this year but every year.”

​ Civil Engagement Group call for equality, transparency and sustainability in Budget 2018.

The Civil Engagement Group in the Seanad is calling on the Government to deliver equality, transparency and sustainable development in Budget 2018. The group have highlighted five principles which they say should underpin the budgetary decision-making. 

1. Budget 2018 must deliver joined-up thinking for sustainable development. 

2. Budget 2018 must prioritise investment in public services and social infrastructure 

3. Budget 2018 must address social, economic and gender inequality 

4. Budget 2018 must be clear and transparent around taxation 

5. Budget 2018 must meet international standards and commitments.